Glad it worked for you. I've seen this happen if you play the original story, go back to main menu, then play random party. The trick is to quit the game and restart.
It would be cool if you could completely customize your own scenario by choosing which girls have which traits. I kinda wanna see what would happen if you did the innocence lost without anyone being the slut. It would be cool experimenting with different combinations and I know you can customize it with personality console commands, but it's a bit hard to do.