I got this happening, by giving her drinks as first action, before officially talking with her. Or just talking first time without getting positive first impressions, and then giving drinks.
I know in some of the couple other places check fails with neutral relations, but not sure exactly where.
[0.9.2] Ashley thinks you are bad person if you have neutral relations with her
Forum rules
Please follow all Eek! Forum rules.
Please follow all Eek! Forum rules.